What Is Sizing Like at Cara Cara? An Honest Stylist's Fit Guide

Cara Cara generally runs true to size through the waist and hips, but the bust and shoulders tend to run snug — so if you're fuller on top, or you're between sizes, size up. That's the short answer, and it's the one I wish someone had given me before I ordered my first Cara Cara dress in what I thought was "my" size and spent a tense ten minutes trying to do up a back zip in a changing room with no air conditioning. Lesson learned, and now I'm passing it on.

Cara Cara is the New York label founded in 2019 by three friends, known for joyful, holiday-spirited prints, crisp cotton poplin and romantic, feminine silhouettes. It's resort dressing with a grown-up polish — and because it's a US brand, the fit logic is a little different to what most of my UK clients are used to. Here's how it actually wears.

How Cara Cara Fits, Piece by Piece

The thing to understand is that Cara Cara isn't one consistent fit — the silhouette dictates everything. After dressing clients in plenty of these pieces, here's the pattern I see again and again:

Floaty printed maxis and tiered styles — their hero pieces — are cut generously through the waist and hips and skim the body beautifully. The catch is up top: fixed-strap and structured-bust versions can pull across the chest and shoulders. Curvy on top? Size up and have the waist taken in if needed.
Smocked-back dresses are the forgiving ones. The elasticated panel gives you a good two-way stretch, so they flatter a range of shapes and are my go-to recommendation for anyone nervous about ordering blind.
Structured occasion pieces with boning or back zips run true at the waist but tighter through the ribcage and bust. These are the trickiest for in-between sizes — there's no give, so the measurements have to be right.
Tie-strap and off-shoulder styles look gorgeous but the straps can slip if you've sized up for the bust. Worth knowing before a long wedding day on your feet.

One more thing for UK shoppers: Cara Cara uses US numeric sizing (0–16) and alpha sizing (XXS–XXL), so the number on the label sits a size or two below the UK equivalent you're used to. Don't panic at the digits — focus on your actual body measurements, not the size you think you "should" be.

My Honest Styling Take

I'll be candid: Cara Cara is an investment, and the prints are the whole point. My genuine fashion win was a poplin midi in a wild fruit print that I've now worn to three garden parties and a christening — it photographs like a dream and the cotton holds its shape all day. My fail? A boned bodice style I ordered in my "usual" without checking the ribcage measurement. Beautiful dress, couldn't breathe in it, sent it back. If a piece has structure, treat the size chart as gospel rather than guessing.

Where to Shop a Similar Look (and Fit) on the High Street

If you love the Cara Cara aesthetic but want to spread the spend — or you simply want a more predictable fit — these are the high street names I'd send clients to for vibrant, feminine, occasion-ready dressing:

Boden — the closest British match for joyful prints and easy summer dresses, with sizing that's reassuringly consistent.
Anthropologie — bohemian, print-led and brilliant for romantic occasion pieces with that collected-on-holiday feel.
Monsoon — long-standing go-to for feminine prints and event dressing at a gentler price point.
Hush — relaxed, pretty prints and effortless silhouettes; great for the everyday version of the Cara Cara look.
Phase Eight — occasion dresses with proper structure, ideal if you want the polish without the boning panic.
Mango — the savviest spot for of-the-moment printed dresses at a fraction of the cost.
Whistles — modern, clean-lined feminine dressing for anyone who likes their prints a touch more pared-back.
Seasalt Cornwall — softer, seaside-inspired prints in cuts that genuinely suit a range of shapes.

Premium & Luxury Alternatives

Want to stay in Cara Cara's world but explore? Here's where I'd look at each level:

ME+EM (premium) — beautifully engineered, travel-friendly dresses with a flattering, considered fit.
Rixo (premium) — the British print specialist; vintage-inspired florals and a forgiving, feminine cut.
La DoubleJ (luxury) — maximalist Italian prints that out-Cara-Cara Cara Cara, if your budget stretches.
Zimmermann (luxury) — the gold standard for romantic, occasion-led resort dressing.
Saloni (luxury) — exuberant prints and dressmaker detailing for the truly special event.

Two Independent Brands Worth a Look

Pink City Prints — a small, family-run label producing hand-block-printed cotton dresses; joyful, ethical, and genuinely one-of-a-kind.
Aspiga — sustainable resort-wear with vivid prints and breezy shapes that capture the Cara Cara holiday spirit at a friendlier price.

Never Guess Your Cara Cara Size Again

Tellar is the UK's leading sizing tool — your body, matched exactly to 1,500+ brands instantly. Measure once using your bust, waist, hip, or an existing brand size, and never squint at a size guide again. Always free, no downloads, works straight in your browser.

Use the Store Size Lookup to get your precise size in any brand — COS, Reiss, Everlane, Arket & more.

Visit Tellar.co.uk Try the Store Size Lookup

More From the Tellar Fashion Hub

A library stacked with free posts from our top stylists. Honest. Unbiased. Independent. And always free — style advice, top picks and the best brands, all in one place.

Always honest, always unbiased, always free. — Ella